RegTech Is RegTech the answer to regulatory efficiency?

Within the last year, a new buzzword analogous to “FinTech” has developed – “RegTech”.

Definition

RegTech is an amalgamation of “regulatory” and “technology”. RegTech companies use new technologies to support efficient regulatory management from an IT perspective within the entire (IT) banking architecture. RegTech services enable the agility and speed that is required for implementing the flood of regulations in an efficient way and use standardized approaches to address the specifics of different data sets. In doing so, RegTech companies make use of innovative technologies such as big data and data visualization techniques, cloud based services, block chain technologies, as well as artificial intelligence elements.

Figure 1: Mapping of RegTech companies to the different architectural layers

There are many use cases where RegTech companies dedicate their services to banks’ business as well as IT architecture (see Figure 1). However, technologies that relate to the business and functional/process perspective, e.g. monitoring tools for managing the large amount of new regulatory initiatives (e.g. zeb.regulatory.information), also have to be considered as RegTech components.

Where does RegTech come from?

Banks are currently facing the specific challenge to manage the flood of new regulatory initiatives which have constantly increased within the last 10 years. Currently, the most complex regulatory driven initiatives are BCBS # 239, SREP, AnaCredit, IFRS 9 and “Basel IV”, which make the achievement of regulatory efficiency a main management topic of interest for nearly every European bank.

Therefore, international finance institutions such as the Institute of International Finance (IIF) and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), have intensified their discussions on the currently developing RegTech industry. However, the conclusions drawn from ongoing RegTech discussions are contrary: Some experts argue that the RegTech market is a promising field as RegTech companies offer efficient IT solutions for a stricter regulatory environment. Others view the future development of the RegTech market with a critical eye since standardized IT approaches are difficult to implement within the banking industry due to the huge differences among banks’ IT architectures and national regulatory reporting requirements in addition to Europe-wide regulation.

Are RegTech companies effectively addressing banks’ current issues in regulatory management?

Today, many banks have a large number of legacy systems in their IT architectures with various overlapping source systems. Furthermore, most of the banks have serious difficulties in implementing an integrated finance and risk architecture. Additional challenges arise from the different capabilities, interfaces and life cycles of technology.

From the process perspective, a complete standardization is a huge ambition since the massive flood of regulatory initiatives very often leads to short-term interim solutions. That is why a harmonization of group wide data definitions, e.g. a business information model, is not available in many banks. Based on this status quo, every required change leads to immense costs, which is one of the main reasons why many banks have established short-term workaround solutions.

Furthermore, there are several software and data solution providers in the market that do already support banks in mitigating the regulatory flood and improving the processing and delivery of data and reports to the relevant authorities. Thus, the replacement of old solutions as well as the integration of new solutions based on new data formats and technologies represent enormous obstacles for the RegTech market. Insufficient collaborations between banks make it even more difficult for RegTech companies to offer standardized solutions for an entire industry. Therefore, regulatory efficiency cannot be achieved as easily as promised by RegTech companies.

Nevertheless, there are opportunities to provide IT solutions in isolated areas (e.g. fraud detection, risk assessment, etc.). But very often, in those isolated areas, excellent and modern software components are already available.

RegTech companies can be a vehicle for all regulatory technologies in banks due to the various interesting ideas, but existing long-term regulatory software components also have to be considered. Therefore, it is important to highlight the relevance of the RegTech companies in order to increase the general awareness of the need for sufficient long-term software solutions in banks.

Thus, the overall challenge for banks is not in implementing the newest RegTech offers as a standalone service and thereby achieving regulatory efficiency with regard to one particular regulatory initiative. Instead, RegTech companies should support banks’ overall journeys to improve regulatory efficiency throughout their entire organization. However, this requires the completion of some prerequisite activities. These include:

  • the simplification of the business and IT architecture by establishing a common target picture (see also BankingHub article on Regulatory Roadmap),
  • the harmonization of data and facilitating of a common understanding of data taxonomies throughout the bank (see also ERF/ BIRD for an initiative driven by authorities),
  • the establishment of a group wide integrated finance and risk architecture,
  • the implementation of data governance and the improvement of data quality,
  • the automation of processes to reduce workarounds.

Furthermore, simplification should be seen by all relevant stakeholders as a sustainable strategic asset for a bank’s future so that the developed standards and the targeted sustainability are incorporated in business action and thought.

Recently, several banks have initiated regulatory programs and the implementation of BCBS # 239 for example has intensified this development even more. However, it has to be emphasized that the journey is a long-term ambition and execution requires not only a strict program management but also perseverance.

As soon as those activities have led to a significant simplification, some new smart technologies may be implemented and could have the potential to significantly reduce banks’ costs for specific compliance issues or improve a bank’s capability to use big data.

Summary

RegTech is a new buzzword which stands for existing as well as new and upcoming IT solutions in the area of regulatory and compliance management. RegTech initiatives stress the importance of regulatory technologies in banks and for this reason can help develop better IT solutions for the future.

However, RegTech services alone will not be able to improve regulatory efficiency within banks. The financial industry will only be able to benefit from RegTech companies’ innovative, smart and technology-based solutions after today’s business and IT architecture within banks has been significantly simplified.

Therefore, the success of RegTech solutions very much depends on the capability of banks to change their target operating model. In summary, “Financial institutions have a primary responsibility for supporting RegTech development, most importantly by creating IT and risk infrastructures that are capable of integrating these new solutions”[1].

[1] Regtech in Financial Services: Solutions for Compliance and Reporting; Institute of International Finance (March 2016), p. 2, https://www.iif.com/node/9994

Don't miss a trend with BankingHub!

Just enter your mail address and you will get the latest analysis and reports from our banking experts – of course free of charge!

I agree to receive this newsletter free of charge and I understand that I can cancel it anytime. 

Sven Krämer

Partner zeb Münster

Dirk Queisner

Senior Manager Office Hamburg

Autoren

2 responses to “RegTech

  • David Jonesу

    Many Fintech companies today spend many resources and management focus on compliance, and virtually all of it (with the notable exception of the legal work) is done in-house. The main reason for that is that for many of these companies, the business use-case is innovative in a way that’s not immediately covered by external providers. Regtech could theoretically help these startups carry some of that load.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Keep up with BankingHub

Just enter your mail address and you will get the latest analysis and reports from our zeb-experts - of course free of charge! I understand that I can cancel the newsletter at anytime.